• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Blog Home
  • Topics
    • Keystone Press Releases
    • Politics and Government
    • Legislation
    • Nevada News
    • Tourism & Gaming
    • Rural Nevada
    • Business
    • Opinion
  • Membership
  • Contact Us
  • About Keystone Nevada

Keystone Nevada Korner

Welcome to The Keystone Korner The Official Blog of Keystone Nevada

Home » EDITORIAL: Court rejects education funding lawsuit. Now, it needs to enforce separation-of-powers clause.

EDITORIAL: Court rejects education funding lawsuit. Now, it needs to enforce separation-of-powers clause.

June 5, 2022 by Pauline Lee

by Las Vegas Review-Journal Editorial Board, June 3, 2022

A lawsuit seeking to upend Nevada’s constitutional structure for allocating education dollars is finally dead.

Last month, the Nevada Supreme Court rejected a legal action brought by the advocacy group Educate Nevada Now and fronted by nine parents, who alleged that Nevada’s public education system fails students. While there’s little disagreement about that, they argued that this required judicial intervention to force lawmakers to raise education spending.

According to the lawsuit — which mirrored similar efforts by education establishment interests in other states to increase school spending — the resources Nevada has devoted to its public schools “fall egregiously short of the sufficiency required by the Nevada Constitution, the laws of this state and the pronouncements and benchmarks set by the state itself.”

As a result, the filing sought to empower judges to set “adequate” school funding levels for lawmakers. The plaintiffs contended that Nevada’s poor student outcomes stem from a lack of resources.

That is a highly dubious assertion. Twice in the past 20 years, the Legislature has passed record tax hikes specifically to fund the public schools. In addition, lawmakers in 2021 imposed a new tax on mining to fund — you guessed it — education. If more money were a panacea for lagging student achievement, there’d be no need to file a lawsuit decrying the state’s poor educational outcomes.

But the bigger issue here is that judges don’t have legislative powers, a point that should be clear to any grade-school civics student. In fact, the Nevada Constitution explicitly bestows lawmakers with the power to determine how much money to allocate for the state’s public education system. And nowhere does it articulate what defines an appropriate level of revenue.

District Court Judge James Wilson dismissed the lawsuit in October 2020. “Consistent with the separation of powers doctrine,” he wrote in a five-page decision, “the court will not substitute its judgment for that of the Legislature with respect to education policy in the state of Nevada.”

Educate Nevada Now appealed, but the Nevada Supreme Court backed up Judge Wilson.

The state of Nevada argues that “the education clauses of the Nevada Constitution do not permit the courts to participate in decisions as to what constitutes an adequate education or what level of funding is sufficient. We agree,” the 6-1 majority wrote. Further, the Nevada Constitution “does not create an obligation for the Legislature to provide public education at a particular service level or to provide specific educational outcomes,” the opinion reads.

This is a basic and welcome application of the separation of powers doctrine. The constitution splits the government’s authority between three separate but equal branches. The power to allocate tax revenue belongs to the Legislature, not the judicial branch.

The more important debate should center on how existing funds are spent. Consider the recent news that the Clark County School District is boosting starting teacher pay by $7,000. That will cost taxpayers a bundle, but there’s little reason to think it will enhance student achievement. It’s not even likely to prevent future teacher shortages. Dumping money into a broken system typically makes a broken system more expensive.

These debates are indeed important to have — at the Legislature.

A statement from Educate Nevada Now indicated the group may file other lawsuits to circumvent Carson City, which means it must have plenty of money to throw down the drain. In the meantime, the group will push a different tactic: “At this time, there is no litigation or court decision to compel lawmakers to act, but that does not mean we as a community cannot demand action. Electing leaders that are willing to do right by our students is more important than ever.”

That’s the group’s right, of course. But the idea that the judiciary can usurp the powers of the Legislature to solve some perceived injustice is dangerous and inherently flawed. Nevada’s courts shouldn’t waste time on it again.

Filed Under: Opinion Tagged With: allocation of education dollars, Clark County School District, District Court Judge James Wilson, Educate Nevada Now

Primary Sidebar

Connect with Us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
Bootleg Bistro
Bootleg Bistro Ad
SLLC_Keystone_Blog-Ad_300x500_10%-Off-Repairs_05.19.21
CIOServices Ad 300x500-100
BRH Keystone Ad JPEG
Willow_Manor
Keystone Corporation Nevada

News Topics

  • Keystone Press Releases
  • Politics and Government
  • Legislation
  • Nevada News
  • Tourism & Gaming
  • Rural Nevada
  • Business
  • Opinion

Rural Nevada

Weather may have slowed January sales

April 8, 2023 By Courtney Holland

By The Record Courier Staff, April 4, 2023 For the third month in a row, Douglas County merchants reported a decrease in taxable sales, though not … [Read More...] about Weather may have slowed January sales

30 new projects in Pahrump: Arby’s, Chipotle, Midas Muffler, 3 convenient stores & more

March 29, 2023 By Courtney Holland

By Robin Hebrock, Pahrump Valley Times, March 28, 2023 Business is booming in the Pahrump Valley, with dozens of new companies looking to bring … [Read More...] about 30 new projects in Pahrump: Arby’s, Chipotle, Midas Muffler, 3 convenient stores & more

UPS and AVK America plan to expand in Douglas County

March 19, 2023 By Courtney Holland

Staff Reports for The Record Courier, March 17, 2023 United Parcel Service plans to build a new 168,000 square foot building in Douglas County, … [Read More...] about UPS and AVK America plan to expand in Douglas County

Redwood Materials gets $2 billion federal loan for mega battery facility near Reno

February 12, 2023 By Pauline Lee

by Jason Hidalgo, Reno Gazette-Journal, February 9, 2023 Redwood Materials just secured a commitment from the federal government for a $2 billion … [Read More...] about Redwood Materials gets $2 billion federal loan for mega battery facility near Reno

Opinion

OPINION: The Lost Art of Negotiation In Carson City

May 30, 2023 By Courtney Holland

NV Dems to Governor Lombardo: ‘Your priorities aren’t our priorities, but here are ours, sign them’ By Megan Barth, The Nevada Globe, May 26, … [Read More...] about OPINION: The Lost Art of Negotiation In Carson City

OPINION: Don’t force taxpayers to gamble with the IRS

May 30, 2023 By Courtney Holland

By Rich Robledo, Las Vegas Sun, May 21, 2023 Every year, millions of Americans visit Las Vegas to see the sights, take in a show, and even gamble … [Read More...] about OPINION: Don’t force taxpayers to gamble with the IRS

OPINION: Bipartisanship is critical in economic development

May 30, 2023 By Courtney Holland

By Tina Quigley, The Nevada Independent, May 28th, 2023 Several months ago, a friend sent me a copy of a 50-year-old local news … [Read More...] about OPINION: Bipartisanship is critical in economic development

Tags

Adam Laxalt am post Build Back Better Business Business Columns Casinos & Gaming Catherine Cortez Masto Clark County Clark County School District COVID Department of Employment Training and Rehabilitation (DETR) Editorials Education Elon Musk employment Gov. Joe Lombardo Gov. Steve Sisolak Housing inflation Inside Gaming Joe Lombardo las vegas Local Local Las Vegas Local Nevada mc-business mc-local mc-news mc-opinion mc-sports Nevada News NPRI Opinion Opinion Columns PAID Politics and Government Real Estate Insider Roe v. Wade school choice Sports Tesla The Strip tourism Victor Joecks

Footer

Copyright © 2023 · Keystone Corporation - All Rights Reserved · Log in
Privacy Policy
By accessing this site, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use

The views, opinions and conclusions expressed by the authors of any article or post on the Keystone Korner are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Keystone Corporation or its officers and board members. Moreover, any reference to a person, party, product or entity does not constitute an endorsement or recommendation by Keystone Corporation or its officers and board members.